Former EC chair Stone sues former ERLC president Moore

In a lawsuit filed Oct. 18, former SBC Executive Committee Chairman Mike Stone alleges he has “suffered a tremendous loss in professional cultivation and reputational standing, decreased future earning power … and serious mental and emotional injury in the form of extreme public embarrassment, stress, anxiety, and fear” due to the actions of former Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission President Russell Moore.

The lawsuit, filed in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee in Nashville, lists a trio of claims for Stone’s legal action: defamation-libel, false light invasion of privacy, and intentional infliction of emotional distress.

The allegations are rooted in a pair of private letters by Moore that were released publicly by unknown sources in May 2021, just weeks before the June 2021 election for SBC president in which Stone was a candidate.

Stone alleges he was defamed by Moore “within the text of two letters strategically concealed from general distribution within the ERLC and the SBC, but then subsequently surreptitiously released,” and that the letters were part of a “malicious campaign” against Stone as retaliation for leading an SBC Executive Committee task force formed in February 2020 that investigated the activities of the ERLC and any impact to Cooperative Program giving caused by the leadership of Moore.

The task force, chaired by Stone, issued its report in February 2021, saying “the current perception of the leadership and direction of the ERLC by many Southern Baptists is a substantial impediment to the growth of the Cooperative Program,” with “potential for a measurable decline in the near future and beyond” if there are not “quick and significant changes in that perception.”

The task force also said its findings showed that “considerable conversation” continues in the SBC “as to the effectiveness and efficiency of the ERLC’s current structure in addressing public policy concerns.”

Though unrelated to the task force findings, Moore left the ERLC at the end of May 2021 to join Christianity Today as its full-time public theologian and to lead a new public theology project.

In addition to the defamation allegations, Stone also alleged Moore’s actions were an attempt to “discredit his campaign for the presidency of the SBC.” Stone announced his candidacy for SBC president in early 2021 but narrowly lost in a runoff to current SBC President Ed Litton, pastor at Redemption Church in the Mobile, Ala., area.

Stone, pastor of Emmanuel Baptist Church in Blackshear, Ga., has been a member of the SBC Executive Committee since 2014 and served as its chairman from June 2018 through June 2020. He is represented in the legal action by Todd G. Cole of Brentwood, Tenn.

The lawsuit states that Stone is seeking damages of at least $750,000 as compensation and alleges that Stone’s “business operations have already been negatively impacted” and his “pastoral efforts will undoubtedly suffer decreased church attendance and a reduction in donations and honorariums because of Defendant’s statements which are untruthful and have cast Plaintiff in a false light.”

Attempts to reach Stone’s attorney, Todd Cole, and Russell Moore were unsuccessful.

— Brandon Porter serves as associate vice president for convention news at the SBC Executive Committee.